Vol. IAutumn MMXXVIPrice: your time

MooseyRates

A ledger of the records, films, series and games that earned their keep, plus a guest column from the cat. Scores out of ten. Opinions out of line.

An engraved moose standing on the deck of a pirate galleon on a red sea
Pl. I. The critic, en route to an opinion.

Frontispiece

The Five

Of all time, across every medium. Signed, sealed, and not up for appeal.

Baldur's Gate 3 1
9.8Moosey rates

Seduce a vampire, interrogate a squirrel, beat a boss by shoving him off a ledge. Two hundred hours in and still finding things. The peak.

M.
Games

Baldur's Gate 3

Larian Studios · 2023

9.8
In Rainbows 2
9.7Moosey rates

Released as pay-what-you-want, which was frankly an insult: it's worth a kidney. 'Reckoner' alone should be prescribed to anyone who thinks they've felt things.

M.
Music

In Rainbows

Radiohead · 2007

9.7
mother! 3
9.6Moosey rates

The most divisive film of the decade, and I'm on the correct side of the divide. A biblical fever dream in one house. People walked out. Their loss.

M.
Film

mother!

Darren Aronofsky · 2017

9.6
True Detective 4
9.5Moosey rates

McConaughey philosophising in a car for eight hours, and I'd happily have watched eighty. Time is a flat circle. So is my rewatch habit.

M.
Series

True Detective

Season One · 2014

9.5
Mass Effect 3 5
9.2Moosey rates

Yes, the ending. I know. But the hundred hours before it are the finest farewell tour in gaming. Tuchanka still gets me. Shepard out.

M.
Games

Mass Effect 3

BioWare · 2012

9.2

Chapter I

Music

Ten records I'd drag out of a burning house, in the order I'd grab them.

In Rainbows 1
9.7Moosey rates

Released as pay-what-you-want, which was frankly an insult: it's worth a kidney. 'Reckoner' alone should be prescribed to anyone who thinks they've felt things.

M.

In Rainbows

Radiohead · 2007

9.7
Takk… 2
9.4Moosey rates

Icelandic for 'thanks', and the only word on it I understood. Didn't matter. 'Hoppípolla' is what a glacier sounds like when it's happy.

M.

Takk…

Sigur Rós · 2005

9.4
…Like Clockwork 3
9.1Moosey rates

Josh Homme nearly died on an operating table and came back with this, which seems a fair trade. Wounded, swaggering, and far sexier than desert rock has any right to be.

M.

…Like Clockwork

Queens of the Stone Age · 2013

9.1
CRAWLER 4
9.0Moosey rates

IDLES stop shouting long enough to say something devastating, then go back to shouting. A car crash of an album, literally and as a compliment.

M.

CRAWLER

IDLES · 2021

9.0
Mordechai 5
9.0Moosey rates

Bass lines so smooth they need a lifeguard. The audio equivalent of a linen shirt on a warm evening. 'Pelota' is compulsory.

M.

Mordechai

Khruangbin · 2020

9.0
This Could Be Texas 6
8.8Moosey rates

Leeds art-rock that won the Mercury and deserved it. Wry, wonky and cleverer than you, but it buys the next round so you let it off.

M.

This Could Be Texas

English Teacher · 2024

8.8
Visions of Light 7
8.6Moosey rates

Bristol jazz that's been left out in the rain and come back stranger. Saxophone drifting through fog. Put it on at 1am and let it do the rest.

M.

Visions of Light

Ishmael Ensemble · 2021

8.6
Eternally Even 8
8.5Moosey rates

My Morning Jacket's frontman goes full cosmic soul and quietly leaves orbit. Lush, political, unhurried. Best heard horizontal.

M.

Eternally Even

Jim James · 2016

8.5
Led Zeppelin III 9
8.4Moosey rates

They retreated to a Welsh cottage with no electricity and came back plugged in anyway. 'Immigrant Song' is half Viking war cry, half air-raid siren. All hair.

M.

Led Zeppelin III

Led Zeppelin · 1970

8.4
HEAL 10
8.2Moosey rates

A man exorcising every demon he owns through a fuzz pedal. Raw, slightly unhinged, and with choruses you'll hum in the shower against your will.

M.

HEAL

Strand of Oaks · 2014

8.2

Honourable mentions

Songs for the DeafA road trip through hell with Dave Grohl on drums. Mind the radio.Axis: Bold as LoveHendrix making a guitar do things guitars aren't licensed to do.So Long ForeverPalace. Heartbreak with excellent reverb.What Kinda MusicTom Misch and Yussef Dayes. Two lads, one groove, infinite head nods.Maggot BrainTen minutes of Eddie Hazel's guitar weeping. You will too.

Chapter II

Film

Ten films worth the popcorn, the overpriced seat and the bloke on his phone in row F.

mother! 1
9.6Moosey rates

The most divisive film of the decade, and I'm on the correct side of the divide. A biblical fever dream in one house. People walked out. Their loss.

M.

mother!

Darren Aronofsky · 2017

9.6
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri 2
9.1Moosey rates

Frances McDormand with a grudge and a lot of plywood. Furious, filthy and very funny, right up until it very much isn't.

M.

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

Martin McDonagh · 2017

9.1
Tenet 3
9.0Moosey rates

Understood about forty per cent of it, enjoyed all of it. The film's own advice applies: don't try to understand it. Feel it.

M.

Tenet

Christopher Nolan · 2020

9.0
The Matrix 4
8.9Moosey rates

Every action film since has been paying rent to this one. Leather coats, bullet time, and the red pill before the internet ruined it.

M.

The Matrix

The Wachowskis · 1999

8.9
Interstellar 5
8.8Moosey rates

A dad, a wormhole and a bookshelf, scored on an organ the size of a cathedral. The docking scene did things to my blood pressure that my GP should know about.

M.

Interstellar

Christopher Nolan · 2014

8.8
Blade Runner 2049 6
8.7Moosey rates

Every frame is a painting. Roger Deakins should be legally required to light everything. Slow as a glacier and twice as beautiful.

M.

Blade Runner 2049

Denis Villeneuve · 2017

8.7
Prisoners 7
8.6Moosey rates

Two and a half hours of rain, dread and Jake Gyllenhaal blinking. Hugh Jackman has never been angrier and I have never been more stressed.

M.

Prisoners

Denis Villeneuve · 2013

8.6
Drive 8
8.3Moosey rates

Gosling says about nine words, wears a scorpion jacket, plays Kavinsky. Then the lift scene. Cooler than you and fully aware of it.

M.

Drive

Nicolas Winding Refn · 2011

8.3
The Dark Knight 9
8.2Moosey rates

Ledger's Joker is the only agent of chaos whose logic is airtight. Not really a superhero film. A crime epic that happens to own a cape.

M.

The Dark Knight

Christopher Nolan · 2008

8.2
Parasite 10
8.1Moosey rates

Starts as a cheeky comedy, ends somewhere in the basement of your soul. You will never look at a peach the same way again.

M.

Parasite

Bong Joon-ho · 2019

8.1

Reputable mentions

No Country for Old MenBardem's haircut is the scariest thing in it, and it has a cattle gun.FargoYah, a masterpiece, you betcha.OppenheimerThree hours of men in hats talking, and somehow a thriller.Saving Private RyanThe first twenty minutes deserve their own medal.The Place Beyond the PinesGosling on a motorbike, and a generation paying for it.The Hateful EightEight liars, one cabin, a great deal of stew.Gangs of New YorkDay-Lewis in a butcher's apron, eating the film whole.Forrest GumpLife is like a box of chocolates. This one's the good one.The Two TowersHelm's Deep. That's the review.The Shawshank RedemptionHope is a good thing. So is this.

Chapter III

Series

Ten reasons I have never once gone to bed at a sensible hour.

True Detective 1
9.5Moosey rates

McConaughey philosophising in a car for eight hours, and I'd happily have watched eighty. Time is a flat circle. So is my rewatch habit.

M.

True Detective

Season One · 2014

9.5
Breaking Bad 2
9.4Moosey rates

A chemistry teacher becomes the worst man in New Mexico and you cheer him on. Says more about you than him, frankly.

M.

Breaking Bad

Vince Gilligan · 2008

9.4
Chernobyl 3
9.3Moosey rates

Five episodes of quiet, radioactive dread. Not great, not terrible. Actually, it's flawless.

M.

Chernobyl

Craig Mazin · 2019

9.3
Fargo 4
9.0Moosey rates

Billy Bob Thornton as a wolf in a parka. Minnesota nice, Minnesota murderous. The Coens' world, somehow improved.

M.

Fargo

Season One · 2014

9.0
Vikings 5
8.8Moosey rates

Ragnar with a smirk and an axe, sailing west because why not. Seasons one to four are a proper saga. We don't talk about after.

M.

Vikings

Michael Hirst · 2013

8.8
Band of Brothers 6
8.7Moosey rates

Easy Company, from Normandy to the Eagle's Nest, and a lump in your throat the whole way. The real veterans' interviews finish you off.

M.

Band of Brothers

HBO · 2001

8.7
Succession 7
8.6Moosey rates

Horrible people, superb insults, four seasons of a family failing upwards. Kendall deserved better. Actually, no, he didn't.

M.

Succession

Jesse Armstrong · 2018

8.6
Severance 8
8.5Moosey rates

Office work, but you split your brain in half to survive it. Relatable. Also the most stylish corporate horror on telly.

M.

Severance

Dan Erickson · 2022

8.5
The Office 9
8.2Moosey rates

Yes, the British one came first. Yes, I've picked the American one. Michael Scott is a tragic genius and I won't be taking questions.

M.

The Office

American edition · 2005

8.2
Game of Thrones 10
8.1Moosey rates

Seasons one to four are some of the best telly ever made. Season eight happened. The average lands here, bruised but proud.

M.

Game of Thrones

HBO · 2011

8.1

Noble mentions

Peaky BlindersBy order of the Peaky Blinders, this gets a mention.Parks and RecreationRon Swanson is a lifestyle. Breakfast food forever.The Last DanceJordan took everything personally, and that's the whole documentary.

Chapter IV

Games

Ten games that cost me sleep, friendships, and roughly a year of my life. No regrets.

Baldur's Gate 3 1
9.8Moosey rates

Seduce a vampire, interrogate a squirrel, beat a boss by shoving him off a ledge. Two hundred hours in and still finding things. The peak.

M.

Baldur's Gate 3

Larian Studios · 2023

9.8
Mass Effect 3 2
9.2Moosey rates

Yes, the ending. I know. But the hundred hours before it are the finest farewell tour in gaming. Tuchanka still gets me. Shepard out.

M.

Mass Effect 3

BioWare · 2012

9.2
God of War 3
8.8Moosey rates

Kratos becomes a dad, which turns out to be scarier than any god. One unbroken shot, an axe that comes when called. BOY.

M.

God of War

Santa Monica Studio · 2018

8.8
Horizon Zero Dawn 4
8.8Moosey rates

Robot dinosaurs versus a bow and arrow: the premise of a ten-year-old, the story of a philosopher. Aloy deserves a statue.

M.

Horizon Zero Dawn

Guerrilla Games · 2017

8.8
Metal Gear Solid 4 5
8.6Moosey rates

Old Snake, nanomachines, and cutscenes long enough to do your tax return during. A glorious, unhinged farewell. Kojima-san, you madman.

M.

Metal Gear Solid 4

Kojima Productions · 2008

8.6
Elden Ring 6
8.6Moosey rates

You will die. A lot. Then you'll spot a castle on the horizon and ride straight at it anyway. Try finger, but hole.

M.

Elden Ring

FromSoftware · 2022

8.6
Heavy Rain 7
8.5Moosey rates

Press X to Jason. Ignore the memes: a properly tense noir that made button prompts feel like life or death.

M.

Heavy Rain

Quantic Dream · 2010

8.5
Detroit: Become Human 8
8.5Moosey rates

Androids, choices, and a flowchart that silently judges you after every chapter. Never felt so guilty about a branching path.

M.

Detroit: Become Human

Quantic Dream · 2018

8.5
Modern Warfare 2 9
8.2Moosey rates

The golden age of lobbies, killstreaks and twelve-year-olds questioning my parentage. Ghost wore the balaclava best.

M.

Modern Warfare 2

Infinity Ward · 2009

8.2
Bloodborne 10
8.3Moosey rates

Gothic Victorian horror where the cure is worse than the disease and the bosses worse than both. Still waiting on that 60fps patch. Still.

M.

Bloodborne

FromSoftware · 2015

8.3

Special mentions

Destiny, co-opThe loot's mediocre. Raiding with mates is sacred.SkyrimYou've played it. I've played it. My fridge has played it.Dark Souls IIIPraise the sun, then die to the Nameless King.Bad Company 2Buildings that fall down when you shoot them. Revolutionary.LittleBigPlanetSackboy. Need I say more.Metal Gear Solid VUnfinished, and still the best stealth sandbox ever made.Modern Warfare (2019)The lighting alone deserves an award.Ghost of TsushimaFollow the wind. Every standoff is pure Kurosawa.Red Dead Redemption 2Arthur Morgan deserved better. So did my horse.

Chapter V · A guest column

Books

Ten books, reviewed by the Long-Haired Black Cat, who sat on every one of them while they were being read. Moosey was not consulted.

The Secret History 1
Approved

Rich students, Greek verbs, and a murder in the snow. Everyone is terrible and beautifully dressed. Read it in one night on the warm bit of the radiator.

L.H.B.C.

The Secret History

Donna Tartt · 1992

The Book Thief 2
Approved

Narrated by Death, who is kinder than you'd think and nearly as patient as a cat. I wept into my own fur. Do not tell the dog.

L.H.B.C.

The Book Thief

Markus Zusak · 2005

Nineteen Eighty-Four 3
Approved

Big Brother is watching you. I have always been watching you. The difference is that I'm adorable about it.

L.H.B.C.

Nineteen Eighty-Four

George Orwell · 1949

To Kill a Mockingbird 4
Approved

Scout is the finest human kitten in literature, and Atticus would give up the good chair for a cat. Quietly, devastatingly decent.

L.H.B.C.

To Kill a Mockingbird

Harper Lee · 1960

The Hobbit 5
Approved

A small creature who adores second breakfast and hates leaving the house. Relatable. The dragon asleep on a pile of treasure is also, frankly, me.

L.H.B.C.

The Hobbit

J. R. R. Tolkien · 1937

The Handmaid's Tale 6
Approved

Every sentence has its claws out. Afterwards I sat very still on the windowsill for an hour, which, admittedly, I do anyway.

L.H.B.C.

The Handmaid's Tale

Margaret Atwood · 1985

The Picture of Dorian Gray 7
Approved

A beautiful creature who never ages and never faces consequences. I fail to see the tragedy. Wicked, witty, and gorgeous on every page.

L.H.B.C.

The Picture of Dorian Gray

Oscar Wilde · 1890

The Bell Jar 8
Approved

Sharp, lonely and luminous, like a cold moon through a window. Not a cosy read. The true ones rarely are.

L.H.B.C.

The Bell Jar

Sylvia Plath · 1963

Piranesi 9
Approved

An endless house of statues and tides, kept by a gentle soul who talks to birds. This is what I dream about when my paws twitch.

L.H.B.C.

Piranesi

Susanna Clarke · 2020

The Color Purple 10
Approved

Letters to God, sisterhood, and a slow, hard-won joy. Celie deserves every good thing, and a sunny spot to lie in.

L.H.B.C.

The Color Purple

Alice Walker · 1982

Worthy mentions

Of Mice and MenShort, sad, and there's a rabbit situation. I had feelings.The Fellowship of the RingNine walkers. Not one cat. Points deducted.The Song of AchillesAchilles is basically a cat: gorgeous, sulky, fast. Patroclus is a saint.The Subtle KnifeA knife that cuts windows between worlds. I'd use it on the fridge.

Ragnar Volarus

In memoriam

Ragnar Volarus

Obsidian, of the Valkyrie Spires · Red Rising

Raised to be a weapon, chose to be a poet. The gentlest giant in fiction and the best friend a Reaper ever had.

May the Valkyrie carry him home.